Woman reacting with confusion during a suspected identity theft scam phone call

The Night I Almost Became a Victim of Identity Theft

When a scam call nearly turned into full-scale identity theft, I learned how easily stress and timing can override even strong technical awareness. This Consumer’s Corner story explores how identity theft happens, what the FBI recommends for protection, and why proactive credit monitoring and identity protection are essential for individuals and families alike.
January 20, 2026

And of course, identity theft was added to my plate...

It wasn’t enough that I was pushing through the end of a nasty upper respiratory infection. Or that I had already rescheduled a long-awaited visit to see my mom—this time to celebrate her 83rd birthday. Hackers and identity thieves don’t care about timing, stress levels, or good intentions.

The call came the evening before an early flight to Nevada. I was finishing up work, wondering whether my antibiotics were doing enough, and still questioning whether I was healthy enough to travel. When my phone rang, I didn’t pause to check the number like I normally would. I answered with a cheerful, distracted, “This is Brea…

How the Scam Almost Worked

The caller identified herself as being from Citibank, calling to verify a charge of nearly $500 at a firearms store made several hours earlier. My radar flickered—our Citibank card had been closed years ago. But my husband had shopped at a firearms store the day before. That coincidence hooked me.

She explained that a card had been opened in my name in Brooklyn and that this was the first charge. She said all the right things: she wouldn’t ask for my Social Security number and only asked me to confirm my name and date of birth.

Still uneasy, I logged into my old Citibank account—no new card appeared. I then checked my credit reports at Experian, TransUnion, and Equifax. I distinctly remembered locking my credit, so no new account should have been possible.

That’s when I realized the truth: after purchasing a car two years earlier, I had never re-locked my credit. I was completely exposed.

When Panic Set In

My husband joined the call after I verified permission (so official). The caller suggested we might want to contact the FBI since firearms were involved. We discussed it briefly—this felt serious, and I didn’t want to carry this worry with me on my trip.

We looked up the FBI number online and prepared to call, but then the caller offered a “solution”: a direct transfer to the New York FBI hotline, complete with background details and case numbers.

Even then, I hesitated. The situation sounded legitimate, but a direct FBI transfer didn’t sit right. When the agent picked up, I immediately requested a callback so I could verify the number.

When the phone rang again, the caller ID displayed the FBI New York Field Office number—but with “Wells Fargo” listed above it.

That was the moment everything clicked.

When I questioned it, the agent sounded irritated: “Ugh, I keep telling them to fix that.” I hung up immediately.

I had been one step away from handing over personal information that could have caused years of damage.

The Reality Check

I’m 51 years old. I work in the technology field. I know what scams look like. I know the risks. And still—I lost 40 minutes, spiked my heart rate, and exposed more information than I should have.

I wasn’t careless. I was overloaded.

Stress, timing, and coincidence created the perfect opening. I was lucky that a programming error on the scammer’s side stopped it. Not everyone gets that break.

What the FBI Recommends for Identity Protection

I turned to the Federal Bureau of Investigation archives to understand what I should have done differently—and how to protect myself moving forward.

4 Ways to View Your Credit Report Annually

Back in the 1990s, requesting a credit report was slow, costly, and arrived by mail weeks later. Today, there are far better options:

  1. AnnualCreditReport.com
  2. The only federally mandated site providing free access to all three credit bureaus every 12 months. Paid options are available for more frequent monitoring.
  3. Go directly to the credit bureaus
  4. You can request reports individually, though this is time-consuming and harder to interpret without seeing all three together.
  5. Through your bank
  6. Many banks offer credit score access directly in your account dashboard, often encouraging deeper monitoring tools.
  7. Financial monitoring services
  8. Some platforms display credit scores as part of a broader financial dashboard. While convenient, these often pull from only one bureau, which can limit visibility.

What the FBI Says Not to Do for Identity Protection

I broke the number one rule—and I still can’t believe it.

  1. Unless you initiate contact, never share personal information via phone, email, or browser.
  2. Never carry your Social Security number, PINs, or passwords in your wallet. Remember—your driver’s license is already there.
  3. Do not write your Social Security number (or allow it to be written) on checks or documents.

How I Chose to Move Forward

I need my technology to work for me in three ways: clear, easy, and sustainable.

Instead of continuing to check my credit once a year, I realized I needed to be more proactive. We’re empty nesters now, and protecting our finances has taken on new meaning. We also have three children in their early 20s learning how to navigate adulthood—and all the risks that come with it.

I chose credit monitoring and identity protection through RC Systems & Support.

What surprised me most was the family dashboard. I can now log into one secure portal and see a summary for each family member: credit scores, number of accounts, debt levels, full credit reports, credit alerts, and identity monitoring—including activity found on the dark web.

This wasn’t just monitoring. It was visibility.

Protecting My Credit Score and Identity in 2026

If another scam call comes in, I’m prepared to:

  1. Always check caller ID and spam warnings
  2. Block suspicious numbers immediately
  3. Keep my credit locked with all three bureaus
  4. Rely on RC Systems technicians for alerts and guidance

I wish I had never received that phone call—but it forced me to stop assuming I was protected and start actually protecting myself.

Now, my family has two powerful tools: knowledge and identity protection.

I never expected a single phone call to expose how vulnerable I really was—but it changed how I think about identity theft and credit monitoring entirely. Protecting your identity isn’t about reacting after something goes wrong; it’s about putting sustainable protections in place before life gets overwhelming.